Death to the BcS

Four of first seven in initial BcS rankings from SEC


Just remember, this is the second-to-last time we have the release of an initial BcS rankings for any given season.

That said, there were few surprises in the first set of BcS rankings released for the 2012 season, even more so when viewed through the prism of half the regular season and conference championship games still remain.

As expected, Alabama, a unanimous No. 1 in both major polls — and the Harris poll, too — is the No. 1 team in the country according to the BcS formula that consists of the coaches’ poll, computers, and the aforementioned Harris poll.  In fact, it’s not even all that close at this way-too-early point in time.

The Tide had a .9761 average in the convoluted BcS formula, while No. 2 Florida stood at .9092; that gap is more than twice as great as the gap between the Gators and No. 5 Notre Dame (.8774).

“The release of the first BCS weekly standings always creates great excitement for college football fans,” BcS executive director Bill Hancock, presumably with a somewhat straight face, said in a statement. “Even though there are still almost two months to go in the regular season, everyone loves to talk about the standings and make projections for the postseason. Whether your favorite team is trying to qualify for a bowl game or trying to make it all the way to the National Championship Game, every game is going to count*.”

(*except for 2011 LSU-Alabama v1.0)

Perhaps the only surprising aspect of the initial release involves Oregon.  Near-unanimous among the human voters as the No. 2 team in the country, the Ducks were just sixth in the computer compilation, dropping UO to No. 3 in the initial release.

The Gators, on the other hand, were at No. 1 among the non-human machines*.  In another computer oddity, Texas Tech, coming off a thumping of then-No. 5 West Virginia in Lubbock, is the No. 7 team in the country according to the computers.

(*for those already asking about the term “non-human machines,” I have two words for you: Nick Saban, coaching cyborg.  If that’s not enough, I’ll gladly delve into the Disney automaton known as Les Miles, carved partially out of actual human flesh.)

Just as expected as Alabama’s spot atop the initial BcS perch, the Tide’s conference is well-represented as well.  Not only does the SEC have four teams in the top seven of the rankings — Alabama, Florida, LSU (No. 6), South Carolina (No. 7) — there are a total of seven — Georgia (No. 11), Mississippi State (No. 12) and Texas A&M (No. 18) being the others — inside the Top 20.

The Big 12 also has seven — three 20th or lower — in the initial Top 25, while the Pac-12 has four.  The Big East has three teams represented, while the Big Ten, with Ohio State ineligible for the postseason due to NCAA sanctions, has no teams in the initial Top 25.

Boise State at No. 22 is the only team from a so-called non-AQ conference in the first set of rankings.

(Much thanks to the National Football Foundation for the chart)

Illinois announces two-year extension for interim head coach Bill Cubit

Bill Cubit
Associated Press
Leave a comment

Illinois has extended year-long interim head coach Bill Cubit for another two seasons, the program announced Saturday afternoon. Does that make him a short-term full-time head coach or a long-term interim coach? Or a combination of the two?

Either way, Cubit is in Champaign to stay through the 2017 season.

A mitigating factor here, undoubtedly, is the absence of a full-time chancellor and a full-time athletics director.

“Bill has stepped in during an extremely difficult period and done an outstanding job in leading our football program since August,” interim athletics director Paul Kowalczyk said in a statement. “Our student-athletes have responded in a positive manner and we feel he is the best person at this time to be the head coach. We wanted to allow Bill to make decisions regarding the program as the head coach without the interim title, and lead the Fighting Illini into Saturday’s game without speculation.”

Cubit’s extended contract will pay him $1.2 million annually. Former Illini head coach Tim Beckman made a reported $1.8 million.

“During the past three months, Coach Cubit has led this team with a steady and experienced hand,” interim chancellor Barbara Wilson said. “He has earned respect and appreciation from all of us. This move will allow the permanent Athletics Director to evaluate the program at his or her own schedule and make decisions based on those evaluations once that search is completed.”

Illinois is 5-6 this season, playing to extend its season at home against No. 16 Northwestern (3:30 p.m. ET, ESPNU).

Tulane announces Curtis Johnson officially out as head coach

Curtis Johnson
Associated Press
Leave a comment

Confirming what was reported earlier this week, Tulane announced Saturday morning it had relieved head coach Curtis Johnson of duties.

Johnson closed his four-year tenure with a 45-34 loss to Tulsa Friday night, a game where the Green Wave led midway though the fourth quarter but were undone by two pick-sixes. He closes his run with a 15-34 record, peaking with a 7-6 mark and a New Orleans Bowl appearance in 2013 but winning only eight games in his other three seasons.

“I want to thank CJ for his hard work and his dedication to rebuilding the Green Wave football program,” Tulane AD Rick Dickson said in a statement. “His efforts were rewarded in 2013 when Tulane reached its first bowl in 11 years. Since then, however, the program has not progressed to the level that we aspire to.”

Similar to Illinois, Central Florida and possibly Rutgers, Tulane says it will find a replacement for Dickson (who originally said he’d step down mid-2016) before finding a new head coach.

Report: Rutgers AD Juile Hermann could be on the chopping block this weekend

Julie Hermann
Associated Press

Many assume Rutgers head coach Kyle Flood won’t survive this disappointing and scandal-ridden fourth season of his. But it could be his boss, the highly controversial Julie Hermann, that receives the ax first.

According to a report from Keith Sargeant of, Hermann could see her 30-month tenure end as soon as this weekend.

“Rutgers athletic director Julie Hermann is expected to meet with university President Robert Barchi before the end of the weekend, three people familiar with the situation told NJ Advance Media on Friday,” Sargeant wrote. “The meeting, presumably called by Barchi, is the first evidence the university’s administration is preparing to act.”

Sargeant writes that Hermann has been kept in the dark while the university conducts a top-to-bottom investigation into the football program’s compliance efforts. Flood was suspended three games and fined $50,000 earlier this season for overriding the church-state relationship between football and academics.

The results of that investigation could find Rutgers joining the ranks of Illinois and Central Florida among schools looking to hire an AD and head football coach at the same time.

“The futures of Flood and Hermann could hang on a report being compiled by the university’s office of enterprise risk management, ethics and compliance,” wrote Sargeant. “The report is expected to detail allegations of failed drug tests and other issues that could result in NCAA infractions and possible sanctions, multiple people familiar with the situation have told NJ Advance Media.”

In addition to a losing season on the field, Rutgers football has dealt with drug suspensions and player arrests off the field this fall.


AD says San Jose State coach Ron Caragher safe for 2016 despite missing bowl game

Ron Caragher
Leave a comment

A 40-23 loss to Boise State Friday condemned San Jose State to a third straight bowl-less season, but Spartans AD Gene Bleymaier said afterwards the setback would not result in a change in job status for head coach Ron Caragher.

“There’s no question about his status,” Bleymaier told the Contra Costa Times. “Ron’s our coach, and he’ll be our coach going forward.”

Hired away from San Diego to replace the departed Mike MacIntyre, Caragher is just 14-22 in three seasons leading the Spartans.

San Jose State did go 6-6 in his debut season of 2013 but did not garner a bowl invite.