At the beginning of the new year, Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Corbett filed a federal antitrust lawsuit against NCAA asking for a complete reversal of the sanctions levied against Penn State last summer in light of the Freeh report on the university’s inaction in the Jerry Sandusky scandal.
The obvious next step was for the NCAA to file a motion to dismiss the suit, and that’s exactly what it’s done. You can view the motion HERE from the NCAA’s official website.
The two arguments of the motion are that the complaint “fails to state a violation of the Sherman Act” and that the “Plaintiff lacks standing to seek injunctive relief.” More specifically, the NCAA argues that its regulation of collegiate athletics is only subject to antitrust scrutiny if it impacts certain economic activity such as television contracts or coaching salaries, and enforcing rules is not a regulation of commerce.
Furthermore, the motion goes back to the consent decree that Penn State approved — the argument against that being that the university had no choice but sign it — and that Corbett does not have standing to sue because he’s not doing so on behalf of anyone subject to antitrust injury.
The NCAA claiming that Corbett is overstepping his jurisdiction is almost too ironic to handle.
I’ve stated before that I believe the NCAA needs to be challenged on its actions against Penn State, although Corbett is admittedly an odd choice to be the one to do so. Corbett was the former Attorney General of Pennsylvania who failed to bring Sandusky, Penn State’s longtime defensive coordinator, to justice for sexually abusing young boys.
Not to mention Corbett said last summer that Penn State must “accept the serious penalties imposed… by the NCAA.”
Political grandstanding at its finest? Yeah, there’s that, but the suit and the motion to dismiss said suit have been filed. Now it’s time to see which direction this case goes in a court of law.
Auburn got back in the win column after two straight losses. While winning a game must have felt nice, head coach Gus Malzahn is not prepared to say whether or not Sean White will be the team’s starting quarterback moving forward.
“I thought he competed; he did some good things,” Malzahn said after the game Saturday, per Al.com. “We’ll take this thing week-to-week like we’ve been doing it. We’re starting to kind of get good answers to the questions that we needed.”
White replaced Jeremy Johnson at quarterback last week against Mississippi State. Johnson, a preseason Heisman favorite for some, struggled out of the gate of the season with six interceptions thrown and a lost fumble. That forced Malzahn to make a change at quarterback after a woeful performance against FCS Jacksonville State and a loss to LSU. White lost his first game as a starter against Mississippi State but the offense has been marginally better. White has yet to throw a touchdown pass in his first two starts.
Against San Jose State, White completed six of 10 pass attempts for 1087 yards. Auburn’s running game is what helped push the Tigers by the Spartans, with Peyton Barber scoring all five touchdowns in the 35-21 victory. Auburn’s next game is in two weeks against Kentucky, on Thursday, October 15 in Lexington.
The Ohio State Buckeyes remain atop the AP Top 25 this week, but the Big 12’s top contenders have bumped Michigan State down two spots. No. 2 TCU picked up five first-place votes and managed to stay ahead of No. 3 Baylor despite the Bears getting 10 first-place votes.
No. 5 Utah picked up seven first-place votes and No. 9 Texas A&M received the last first-place vote available. The big mover in this week’s AP poll was No. 11 Florida, with the Gators jumping 14 spots in the poll after dismantling Ole Miss Saturday night. The Rebels dropped from No. 3 down to No. 14. No. 15 Notre Dame fell nine spots after losing at No. 6 Clemson. No. 19 Georgia also tumbled this week, down 11 spots after being blown out at home by Alabama. It was also a rough week for No. 20 UCLA, falling 13 spots after losing to Arizona State at home.
New teams in the AP poll this week include No. 22 Iowa, No. 24 Toledo and No. 25 Boise State. Iowa and Boise State also made appearances in the coaches poll earlier today, but Toledo did not. Memphis appears in the coach spill but is the third team in its own conference in the others receiving votes category, behind Houston and Temple. Memphis tied with division foe Navy in that category as well.
- Ohio State (38 first-place votes)
- TCU (5)
- Baylor (10)
- Michigan State
- Utah (7)
- Texas A&M (1)
- Florida State
- Ole Miss
- Notre Dame
- Oklahoma State
- Boise State