It’s been two days since “Outside the Lines” released a report claiming the NCAA was looking into whether Texas A&M quarterback Johnny Manziel signed memorabilia for money. Yesterday, the story was pushed forward with a new allegation which focused on Manziel’s friend and personal assistant that could also bring Manziel’s eligibility into question via the Cam Newton rule.
Today was no different. ESPN’s Joe Schad writes in a report that Manziel received $7,500 from an “East Coast autograph broker” in exchange for signing “approximately 300 mini- and full-sized helmets on Jan. 11-12 while he was attending the Walter Camp Football Foundation event.”
The broker showed Schad two videos, which he said were taken without Manziel’s knowledge, of the Heisman winner signing memorabilia. However, the videos, which the broker initially tried to sell to ESPN, do not show any exchange of money.
This probably won’t be the last report that surfaces about Manziel and autographs, so the process of really moving the story forward comes down to this: is there hard evidence of Manziel receiving money for his signature? Technically speaking, Manziel has to comply with the NCAA during an investigation. That includes opening up his bank statements and explaining some possibly big-time purchases.
If the NCAA can’t find anything, however, pinning down a transaction (or multiple transactions) could be significantly harder to do. The broker, who was not named in the latest ESPN piece, said he does not intend to cooperate with the NCAA.
Likewise, the other anonymous autograph broker from Monday’s story told ESPN he had declined to answer six calls from the NCAA. The broker in OTL’s original Sunday report, Drew Tieman, didn’t even reply to ESPN’s requests for comment, so it’s doubtful he’d cooperate with the NCAA. In that vein, anyone else potentially of interest to the NCAA who’s close to Manziel, such as his family or friend/personal assistant, Nate Fitch, doesn’t have to cooperate either.
That would put the Association in a tough spot, and A&M has lawyered up by retaining the legal services of Lightfoot, Franklin and White, who helped Auburn keep Cam Newton eligible in 2010.
It’s far too early to tell if Manziel will face any type of suspension or punishment in this case — if he broke NCAA bylaws to begin with — but the odds appear to be stacking up against the NCAA.