The topsy-turvy Heisman race reach finally gained some order on Saturday night as Florida State quarterback Jameis Winston took home the trophy in a landslide.
Lost in the shuffle, however, was the fact that Alabama quarterback A.J. McCarron was a surprise runner up.
It’s not the first time a McCarron achievement has been downplayed. His 36-3 record as a starter, his school-record 8, 243 passing yards and 72 touchdown passes, his nation-leading pass efficiency rating as a junior — it didn’t really seem to resonate with a lot of the punditry who cover college football.
Nonetheless, Heisman voters seemed to understand, viscerally, what he meant to his team.No other Alabama quarterback has finished this high in the Heisman standings before. His recognition by the Heisman electorate is a fitting testament to a remarkable career that is coming to a close.
McCarron’s support in the Heisman vote was solid. He received the most second-place (162) and third-place votes (143) and the second-most first-place votes (79). He finished second in three of the six voting regions and third in the other three.
One wonders how the vote might’ve changed if the Tide hadn’t fallen in freaky fashion to Auburn. McCarron would’ve had another chance to show his stuff in the SEC title game and maybe a gallant performance there would’ve swayed more voters his way. At the very least, the race would’ve been a lot closer.
McCarron will go down as perhaps the greatest quarterback in Alabama history. It’s not going to be easy to replace him.