Sometimes good intentions come at a price that just cannot be realized until something is put in to effect. When Coca-Cola decided to change their formula to compete with a customer base swaying more and more to the sweeter taste of Pepsi, they came up with New Coke. It seemed like a good idea at the time, but when it finally hit the market it quickly became one of the biggest flops in the history. The NCAA’s targeting rules in 2013 may have followed a similar path, and they are ready to review the potential fixes needed in 2014.
Today the NCAA’s Football Rules Committee proposed to amend the targeting rules with regard to the 15-yard penalty following an instant replay. As it was enforced last fall, any player flagged for targeting a defenseless player was subject to an automatic ejection and his team was penalized 15-yards. However, if an instant replay determined an ejection was not warranted that player could return t the game immediately. The 15-yard penalty remained assessed though. That could change.
According to a release issued by the NCAA, the Football Rules Committee is proposing wiping off the 15-yard penalty any time an instant replay allows a player to re-enter the game.
“Overall, the targeting rule was successful and has had the intended impact of making play safer,” said Troy Calhoun, head coach at the Air Force Academy and chair of the committee. “This alteration keeps the intent of the rule, but allows replay to correct all of the consequences from a rare missed call.”
In other words, common sense will prevail. While there are still issues with the way targeting is interpreted from conference to conference and from officiating crew to officiating crew, one of the biggest problems with the rule from the start was still assessing a penalty for something an instant replay review determined should not have been flagged in the first place.
This is an amendment that should be passed without hesitation.
In addition to the targeting rules amendment, the committee also recommended allowing defensive substitutions in the first 10 seconds of the 40-second play clock. The intent is to improve player safety, of course. The proposal was made to ensure defensive players have a chance to get off the field against teams with up-tempo offenses that rarely use the entire play clock. Of course, wearing down the defenses was always one of the perks of a quick offense so if the proposal is passed it will be interesting to see if the quick offensive styles are slowed down at all. If so, this proposal could turn out to be a real game changer.
College GameDay was in Times Square on Saturday and decided to do the most New York thing possible: respond to a Mike Francessa rant.
Francessa ripped Penn State head coach James Franklin, calling him a “horses’s ass,” for trying to prevent a field goal to preserve the Nittany Lions’ 56-0 blanking of Georgia State last week. To respond, ESPN didn’t talk to Franklin, but instead asked comedian (and Penn State graduate) Keegan-Michael Key to speak for him.
This is not the first time Key has leverages his resemblance to Franklin for comedic purposes.
Nevertheless, Franklin addressed the bit to close his post-game press conference following Penn State’s 21-19 escape of Iowa in an answer that toed the line between seriousness and wry sarcasm.
Boston College will be without wide receiver Charlie Callinan for “an extended period of time,” the program announced just before the Eagles’ date with Clemson on Saturday.
Callinan suffered a foot injury. The nature of the injury was not disclosed.
A senior from Westfield, N.J., Callinan was one of the most experienced players on the roster with 41 career appearances and 31 starts under his belt. He is the third BC player with at least 30 career games to be lost for an extended period of time this season.
Callinan posted the best game of his career in what may go down as the final game of his career, hauling in seven catches for 89 yards and two touchdowns in a 49-20 loss to Notre Dame a week ago.
Without him in the lineup, BC passed for 141 yards on 34 attempts in a 34-7 loss to the second-ranked Tigers.
Saquon Barkley is incredible. The Penn State running back is every bit a deserving Heisman front-runner, what with his 66 carries for 518 yards and four touchdowns, his team-leading 23 grabs for 335 yards and two touchdowns, and his 22.86-yard average on seven kickoff returns. This isn’t a criticism of him.
But I want to introduce an idea to you right now, and I want you to take a deep breath first: it’s possible Barkley is not having the best season of any running back in college football. At least not to this point.
Take a look at Stanford’s Bryce Love‘s first four games:
- 13 carries for 180 yards and a touchdown in a 62-7 destruction of Rice
- 17 carries for 160 yards and a touchdown in a 42-24 loss to USC
- 13 carries for 184 yards and two scores in a 20-17 loss to San Diego State
- 30 carries for 263 yards and a touchdown in last night’s 58-34 defeat of UCLA
Add it all up and you get 73 carries for 787 yards and five touchdowns, which not only means Love leads the nation in rushing yards per game — he leads the nation in rushing while averaging 10.78 yards per carry.
Love not only leads the nation in total rushing yards, he not only leads the nation in rushing yards per game, he leads the nation in yards per carry for all players anywhere in the neighborhood his carry total. Four players rank ahead of Love in yards per carry thus far, and those three players have toted the rock 76 times — combined.
The next closest player on the yards per carry rankings with at least 70 rushes is San Diego State’s Rashaad Penny, who averages 7.87 yards on 91 carries. That’s an incredible number, and still 27 percent lower than Love’s average.
Stanford may not win enough for Love to join Barkley in the Heisman conversation, but right now it appears the two running back spots on every All-American team are locked up until further notice.
Big wins over ranked opponents pushed Georgia and TCU into the top 10 of the latest Associated Press poll, released Sunday. Voters were apparently more impressed with Georgia’s 31-3 whipping of then-No. 17 Mississippi State in Athens than they were of TCU’s 44-31 upset of then-No. 6 Oklahoma State in Stillwater. Georgia moved up four spots while TCU jumped seven, but the Bulldogs remained ahead of the Frogs by two spots, No. 7 to No. 9.
Elsewhere, Washington creeped forward one spot, Washington State and Louisville nudged forward two, and South Florida, San Diego State and Utah leaped three spots forward. Notre Dame and West Virginia returned to this week’s poll at Nos. 22 and 23, replacing upset losers Florida State and Oregon. Unlike the Coaches’ Poll, voters remembered that Mississippi State hammered LSU by 30 points just eight days ago, keeping the Bulldogs one spot ahead of the Bayou Bengals.
The full poll:
- Alabama — 1,515 total points (52 first-place votes)
- Clemson — 1,458 (2)
- Oklahoma — 1,397 (1)
- Penn State — 1,304
- USC — 1,247
- Washington — 1,188
- Georgia — 1,136
- Michigan — 1,088
- TCU — 1,028
- Wisconsin — 1,023
- Ohio State — 1,016
- Virginia Tech — 828
- Auburn — 701
- Miami — 693
- Oklahoma State — 665
- Washington State — 551
- Louisville — 502
- South Florida — 406
- San Diego State — 365
- Utah — 356
- Florida — 342
- Notre Dame — 246
- West Virginia — 212
- Mississippi State — 148
- LSU — 92