MAACO Bowl Las Vegas - Arizona State v Boise State

March Madness upsets sparking the College Football Playoff argument again


The Atlantic Sun champions from Mercer took advantage of their 14-seed by taking down Duke in the first round in Raleigh, North Carolina Friday afternoon. As is expected whenever something like this happens in the world of college basketball, the inevitable question about seeing something similar happen in college football popped up on Twitter.

Again, comparing college football to college basketball is like comparing apples and oranges. There are too many differences between the two sports and the way they operate to even make it a worthwhile discussion. Even with the start of the brand new College Football Playoff coming our way this 2014 season is not enough to start making comparisons between the two sports and their respective postseason formats.

College football has the BCS busters that have provided some great memories and moments at times. Boise State was put on a map thanks to their trademark blue turf, but it was an upset of Oklahoma that made the Broncos a legitimate household name. Utah managed to win a pair of BCS bowl games against Pittsburgh and Alabama, no small feat that has helped raise their profile to be attractive enough for an invite to join the Pac 10 (now the Pac 12, of course). Others, such as Hawaii and Northern Illinois, have been less fortunate against the bluebloods of the sport, which is similar to the fate most of the heavy underdogs in basketball’s postseason experience.

It’s true. Imaginations run wild when Dayton beats Ohio State and Florida Gulf Coast beats Georgetown, but we are collectively reluctant to embrace the same when Boise State crashes a BCS bowl game or Northern Illinois or Fresno State are making a run. Why is that? For some reason when it comes to football, many prefer to see the teams with the most talent play because the expectation is a more competitive game is more likely.

Instead of spending time wishing college football’s playoff system set a stage for similar March Madness drama or arguing in favor of the sanctity of the regular season, maybe we should just enjoy each sport for what they are. Both are pretty great.

Rutgers reinstates WR Leonte Carroo to football team

SEATTLE, WA - AUGUST 28:  Wide receiver Leonte Carroo #4 of the Rutgers Scarlet Knights makes a touchdown catch on the first play of the game against the Washington State Cougars at CenturyLink Field on August 28, 2014 in Seattle, Washington.  (Photo by Otto Greule Jr/Getty Images)
Getty Images
Leave a comment

While the news of late has been littered with the exits of two SEC wide receivers, one team from the Big Ten is welcoming back a player who plays the same position.

In a press release, Rutgers confirmed that Leonte Carroo has been reinstated to the Scarlet Knights football program.  The release stated that head coach Kyle Flood, who is suspended himself, “reinstated Carroo after the student-athlete agreed to the conditions of his reinstatement and after he accepted the responsibility that comes with his return to the team.”

The reinstatement comes one day after a domestic violence charge against him was dropped after the alleged victim decided not to testify against he former boyfriend.  Carroo had been accused of slamming a woman with whom he had a previous relationship into the concrete outside of the RU football facility last month.

Carroo has missed the last two games (Penn State, Kansas) because of the suspension.  He will be eligible to return to practice today and play in Saturday’s game against 10th-ranked Michigan State.

Despite missing those two contests, Carroo is still tops on the team in receiving yards with 181 and tied for the team lead with three receiving touchdowns.  He’s also averaging nearly 26 yards per reception.

Carroo led the Scarlet Knights last season in receptions (55), receiving yards (1,086) and receiving touchdowns (10).

Pig Howard dismissed by Vols

KNOXVILLE, TN - OCTOBER 5: Pig Howard #2 of the Tennessee Volunteers fumbles the ball through the end zone during overtime of the game against the Georgia Bulldogs at Neyland Stadium on October 5, 2013 in Knoxville, Tennessee. (Photo by Scott Cunningham/Getty Images)
Getty Images

It’s been a bad week for talented SEC wide receivers.

On the heels of Auburn giving the boot to D’haquille Williams following an alleged bar rampage, Tennessee announced Wednesday that Pig Howard has been dismissed from Butch Jones‘ football program.  Violations of unspecified team rules was the only explanation offered.

Howard had been suspended for the season opener for the same reason due to an unspecified incident several months before.  It’s unknown if the dismissal is related in any way to that suspension.

Injuries had allowed the senior to play in just two games this season, against Oklahoma and Western Carolina.  He had one reception for eight yards, with that coming in the overtime loss to the Sooners.

The past two seasons, Howard led the Vols in receiving with 54 and 44 receptions in 2014 and 2013, respectively.  He accounted for 1,006 receiving yards in that span, and has also scored a pair of rushing touchdowns.