College Football Playoff selection committee members will be tasked with finding the best teams in college football to participate in the new playoff model. This much we already knew, but on Wednesday more details and explanations started to come out about just how the process will be conducted. Arkansas athletics director Jeff Long, chairman of the committee, says the committee will focus on the best teams and not necessarily worry about finding the most deserving teams.
Jeff Long says it’s not most DESERVING teams, but the focus is the BEST four teams that shall get into the bracket
— Joe Schad (@schadjoe) April 30, 2014
The hope is the best teams actually will be the most deserving teams, but that could also make it more difficult for some programs to crack the new postseason format. Think about a Boise State program going 13-0 with a Mountain West Conference championship being stacked up a pool of one-loss champions from the ACC, Big 12, Big Ten, Pac-12 and SEC. Where might Boise State fit in that mix? The Broncos, despite putting together a worthy season that would have likely clinched a spot in the old BCS line-up, could now be on the outside looking in once again, in theory.
This can actually go a long way to enforcing the argument playoff detractors have had all along, that the value of the regular season could be devalued as a result of the direction of the selection committee. Of course, perhaps this will all work out just fine once we get into the thick of things in the fall.
The selection committee will begin unveiling a top 25 ranking every Tuesday in late October. The revealing of the updated ranking will be aired by ESPN with the intent of explaining the selection committee’s logic behind the rankings.
Compiling those rankings could be a massive project. The entire committee will go through a detailed process to put together a consensus top 25 ranking. Long says the committee will begin working on the latest rankings each Monday and will work up to 24 hours with breaks for food until the job is complete.