APWord broke last night that Sports Illustrated would be publishing a piece that was highly critical the lingering sports culture at Penn State in general and the medical care given to student-athletes specifically.
The university responded swiftly, releasing a statement that called the SI report “erroneous” and is essentially an attempt to “sensationalize” a non-issue. Wednesday afternoon, PSU’s defense of its medical procedures ramped up another notch or two.
Appearing on ESPN‘s “College Football Live” program, head coach Bill O’Brien lashed out at the report, which is not available in full online but a summary can be viewed by clicking HERE. O’Brien stated that he’s heard from a handful of current and former Nittany Lion football players who would like to know what they can do “to get in front of this” apparently scathing six-page report.
“We here at Penn State would never jeopardize the health and safety of our players. We don’t have any horse in that race,” O’Brien said in quotes provided by PennLive.com. “It’s very upsetting to me that the word out there is that we don’t have proper care for our student-athletes.”
O’Brien added that “the only thing that matters to me” is the safety of his players.
The SI report was particularly critical of the fact that O’Brien made suggestions regarding the medical care of his players, including parting ways with long-time team doctor Wayne Sebastianelli. O’Brien stated that he merely made the recommendation; it was up to his superiors to make the final call on a change in medical personnel.
“At the end of the year, I met with [athletic director Dave] Joyner and Rod Erickson about a lot of improvements that needed to be made,” O’Brien said. “My recommendation was to move in another direction with the doctors on this team. I don’t do the hiring and firing. That’s for the people above me.”
In addition to O’Brien’s television appearance, Penn State also issued a series of new statements questioning the credibility of the piece. The one below comes from Dr. Harold Paz, senior vice president for Health Affairs, Chief Executive Officer, Penn State Hershey Medical Center and dean of the College of Medicine:
“The article suggests that the quality of care provided to Penn State student athletes has been jeopardized by a change in team physicians. It simply isn’t the case. Drs. Seidenberg and Lynch, the physicians now responsible for the day-to-day care of Penn State football players are both experienced clinicians, fellowship-trained in Sports Medicine and committed to providing expert medical care to our students athletes.
“Any suggestion that care is being compromised by the change in physician assignments is both unsubstantiated and incorrect.
“The article further suggests that Dr. Sebastianelli is no longer playing a role in supporting the University’s athletic teams. In fact, as Director of Athletic Medicine, Dr. Sebastianelli remains the doctor in charge of the University’s entire medical program for intercollegiate athletics.”
A general statement released by the university begins by claiming that “[t]he article fundamentally distorts the facts,” including the very premise of the article.
“There has been no change in the model of medical care for our student athletes. The allegations on why the change in team physician was made is ludicrous. Worst of all, the article ignores the fact that Dr. Sebastianelli remains the doctor in charge of the University’s entire medical program for intercollegiate athletics, including football. In addition, the university athletic trainer reported directly to Dr. Sebastianelli, who supervised the trainer’s work. A review shows Penn State’s medical coverage is on par with, or exceeds, peer institutions.”
To show just how their medical coverage compares to other institutions, Penn State sent out yet another press release titled “Football Physician In-Season Coverage” in which the medical coverage of other major FBS football programs is compared to the system in place at Penn State:
Penn State
- Primary care physician attends all practices and games. On Sunday, examines every player who played in the game previous day and any others in need of attention.
- Orthopedic physician attends at least one practice each week (Wed.) and all games. Available post-practice Monday, Tuesday and Thursday if necessary. On Sunday, is available to examine all players.
Iowa
- Primary care physician is available to attend practice and see players post-practice Monday-Friday. On Sunday, is available to examine all players.
- Orthopedic physician is available post-practice Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday. On Sunday, is available to examine all players.
LSU
- Primary care physician available post-practice Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday. On Sunday, is available to examine all players.
- Orthopedic physician available post-practice Tuesday and Wednesday. On Sunday, is available to examine all players.
Michigan State
- Primary care physician is available to attend practice and see players post-practice Monday-Friday. On Sunday, is available to examine all players.
- Orthopedic physician is available post-practice Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday. On Sunday, is available to examine all players.
Northwestern
- Primary care physician is available to attend practice and see players post-practice Monday-Friday. On Sunday, is available to examine all players.
- Orthopedic physician is available post-practice once or twice a week. On Sunday, is available to examine all players.
Nebraska
- Primary care physician is available to attend practice and see players post-practice Monday-Friday. On Sunday, is available to examine all players.
- Orthopedic physician is available post-practice Tuesday and Wednesday. On Sunday, is available to examine all players.
Ohio State
- A primary care physician is available to see players early a.m. Monday-Friday and post-practice on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday. On Sunday, the physician is available to examine all players. Attends all games.
- An Orthopedic physician is available to see players post-practice on Tuesday and Wednesday. On Sunday, is available to examine all players. Attends all games.
- At least one of the three team physicians attends practice or a part of practice every day and sees players at the conclusion of each practice as needed for new injuries or follow-up care.