What was supposed to be a memorable night honoring BYU legend Jim McMahon turned sour in a hurry late in the first half. Utah State (3-2) scored 21 points in the final five minutes of the first half and No. 18 BYU (4-1) lost quarterback Taysom Hill for the rest of the season to a broken leg suffered just before halftime. Utah State snapped BYU’s big bowl dreams with a 35-20 victory in Provo Friday night.
Hill was looking like a Heisman candidate, offering the same sort of season Northern Illinois had seen with Jordan Lynch in recent seasons. Hill suffered the injury when attempting to roll out to the sideline on a second-and-long. His leg was rolled on in a tackle attempt by Utah State’s Brian Suite. The irony of the injury was it was Suite who was involved in a play that ended Hill’s 2012 season as well.
After the game BYU head coach Bronco Mendenhall said Hill will undergo surgery today. It is expected to take three or four months for Hill to recover from the injury, meaning we have seen the last of Hill on the football field this season.
Utah State was already taking control of the game when Hill went down. The Aggies had just tied the game at 14-14 late in the first half when a botched exchange between Hill and BYU running back Jamaal Williams was recovered by Utah State on BYU’s first play from scrimmage of the ensuing possession. The Aggies went right for the end zone with a 22-yard pass from Darell Garretson to Devonte Robinson for a 21-14 lead. BYU’s next drive lost momentum when Hill was taken off the field with the injury. The Cougars punted and Utah State took over for one last possession starting from their 13-yard line, but on first down from the 28-yard line Garretson launched a deep pass down the right sideline to Hunter Sharp, who took it 72 yards for a touchdown, giving Utah State a commanding, and deflating 28-14 into the half. This all happened in a span of three and a half minutes, but it must have felt like an eternity for BYU.
Utah State, now without their star quarterback Chuckie Keeton for the remainder of the year, scored a major victory for the program. This was not a conference game, but the Aggies won their first game on the road this season and now look to have some confidence to move through Mountain West Conference play moving forward. Last year Utah State advanced to the conference championship game without Keeton, and if Friday night was any indication, these Aggies have what it takes to make a return trip to the conference championship game again.
BYU’s bowl picture is pretty simple. The Cougars are locked into a trip to the Miami Beach Bowl as long as they qualify for bowl eligibility. BYU only needs two more wins to become bowl eligible, which still should be a lock even without Hill. But the season started off so strong for BYU and the Cougars were making a case to be considered for a New Years Bowl slot if things continued to develop the way it seemed they could. BYU likely needed to run the table for that to be the case though, which means BYU will likely be sticking with the Miami Beach Bowl.
Week 5 means it’s time for Arkansas and Texas A&M’s trek to the Dallas/Ft. Worth metroplex for their annual conference game at AT&T Stadium but the days of the old SWC-turned-SEC West rivals meeting in the area might be on the way out.
While a number of fans on both sides have clamored for a return to campus sites for the yearly division meeting, it seems they have picked up a key ally in new athletic director Ross Bjork, who gave some pretty strong indications to the Dallas Morning News that the series is unlikely to continue after the contract runs out after 2024.
“Here’s how I should view it: we should have every SEC home game on our campus from here on out,” Bjork said. “How we do that after the contract is over is still yet to be determined. I think we should have four SEC home games every single year on our campus.”
Bjork said he has spoken about the series with his counterpart at Arkansas, who has even more of a juggling act to do given that Dallas Cowboys owner Jerry Jones (a former player and prominent booster) enjoys hosting his old team at his palace of a stadium. Still, the Razorbacks have to be interested in a return to campus in at least some form given that they also play a number of games in Little Rock and have just two SEC games in Fayetteville some years — including in 2019.
We’ll see what ultimately becomes of the Arkansas-Texas A&M dance in Dallas but the comments out of College Station right now certainly put it on a path to ending in the near future.
There’s giving back as a former player and then there’s giving back to your old program.
The latter was certainly the case for Syracuse this weekend as the school announced a record $25 million gift from former offensive guard John Lally during their game against Western Michigan at the Carrier Dome.
“For Syracuse University Athletics to become even more competitive in both the ACC and on the national stage, the program needs to have first-class facilities, operations and support,” Lally said in a statement. “Laura and I are committed to Syracuse University Athletics, and in particular positioning the university to attract, recruit and retain high-performing student-athletes who succeed on and off the field, inside and outside the classroom and in their communities.”
Lally made his money as the owner and president of PCB Piezotronics Inc., a company he founded after playing offensive guard for the Orange from 1977 to 1981.
While the extra large gift didn’t have any specifics attached to it, the size certainly points to at least some minor facilities upgrades. According to Syracuse.com, Lally already donated nearly $1 million for renovations to the Carrier Dome prior to writing an even bigger check on Saturday in the middle of the Orange’s victory over the Broncos.
It’s not uncommon but for players, especially those in the NFL, to pony up for a new locker room or weight room at their old program but the size of Lally’s generosity is certainly notable in a very welcome gift for Syracuse.
There were some absolute bonkers endings in the Pac-12 this weekend, from the #Pac12AfterDark special that was UCLA’s comeback against Washington State, to Colorado stunning Arizona State to California remaining the league’s only undefeated team thanks to a goal line stand against Ole Miss.
While the Golden Bears escaped Oxford with a 28-20 win, the victory was not without controversy — something Rebels officials want answers on.
For those who didn’t catch the action, Ole Miss was down eight in the final minute. After a big pass play got the team into the red zone, the Rebels faced 3rd-and-goal from the three yard line with just 17 seconds left. QB John Rhys Plumlee rolled out and quickly threw it to Elijah Moore right at the goal line.
Officials, who were from the Pac-12, ruled Moore short of the end zone however and marked him down inside the one yard line. The home team had no timeouts left and scrambled to get a QB sneak in, which was stuffed by Bears linebacker Evan Weaver.
Ole Miss interim athletic director Keith Carter took to Twitter to express his frustration over Moore’s catch not being reviewed (which would have stopped the clock) as to whether he broke the plane or not, not holding back at all at the Pac-12 officials involved.
The conference has already acknowledged an error their crew made in Arizona State’s victory over Michigan State last week, where Pac-12 refs missed a call that would have allowed the Spartans to get a first down on a missed field goal. Something could be released on Sunday afternoon but that’s unlikely to appease the Rebels, who now sit at 2-2 on the year and face the always brutal SEC slate over the coming months.
All of which Pac-12 fans probably shrug their shoulders over and say get in line Ole Miss given the mistakes the league’s officials make on a weekly basis out West.
AP Poll voters shook up their ballots quite a bit after a fairly wild Week 4 of action in college football.
Among the biggest risers are No. 15 Cal, which celebrated a controversial victory at Ole Miss on Saturday to become the Pac-12’s only unbeaten and now the conference’s second-highest ranked squad after No. 13 Oregon. The folks out West had a number of movers and shakers when all was said and done, with previously ranked Arizona State and Washington State dropping out after losses and No. 21 USC returning to the top 25 after beating a Utah squad now ranked No. 19 on Friday night.
One of the big drops came at the hands of new No. 22 UCF, which had been sitting in the top 15 prior to losing at Pitt on Saturday in a wild one from Heinz Field. That left new No. 16 Boise State as the highest ranked Group of Five team. Michigan State also returned to the rankings at No. 25 while Kansas State is now ranked in both the AP and Coaches Polls after an idle week. No. 23 Texas A&M hung on to a number in front of their name after a second loss to a top 10 team while Michigan dropped nine spot and sat at No. 20 after being destroyed by Wisconsin.
In the top 10, Notre Dame stuck around after their close loss to Georgia, the Badgers moved to No. 8 and Oklahoma and Ohio State flipped spots in the 5/6 range after the Sooners were off and the Buckeyes scored 76 unanswered against Miami (OH).
Here’s the full AP Poll heading into Week 5:
- Ohio State
- Notre Dame
- Penn State
- Boise State
- Texas A&M
- Kansas State
- Michigan State