Leonard Williams’ disappointment in All-American status exposes flaw in roster

13 Comments

There is an inherent flaw in the naming of Walter Camp’s All-American teams at a particular position

The reaction from USC Leonard Williams after being named a Second-Team All-American perfectly illustrates the issue.

Williams wasn’t happy when the announcement was made Thursday:

Williams should be disappointed. There appears to be a built-in bias against interior defenders along the defensive line.

All four of the First-Team All-Americans named this year are defensive ends. Only one defensive tackle was included last year. The last time a pair of defensive tackles were named to the First-Team Walter Camp All-American team was in 2011.

Flashy stats seem to outweigh quality play by those that do more of the dirty work. It’s not hard to figure out the reasoning behind the four defensive linemen named to the first team this year. All four were among the college football’s top seven in sacks.

Whereas Williams finished the season with six sacks. But that’s certainly not a reflection in his level of play.

There are major differences in styles of play between each of these players. Williams was dominant this season, but he’s starts as a 3-4 defense end. Williams isn’t an edge rusher whose primary job is getting to the quarterback. He plays all along USC’s defensive line, and his play was as good as anyone that was named to the first team.

Washington’s Danny Shelton was also named to the second team. As a pure nose tackle, Shelton’s production was unbelievably impressive. The mammoth defensive tackle was second on Washington’s roster with 89 total tackles. He finished with 16.5 tackles for loss and nine sacks. Those are numbers that nose tackles simply don’t post all that often. Yet it wasn’t good enough to be named to the first team.

A differentiation between positions along the defensive line should be prioritized by the Walter Camp Football Foundation. Not all positions and systems are created equally, but the players in them can be as dominant as those posting better overall numbers.

Mizzou confirms Eli Drinkwitz will retain Brick Haley

Getty Images
1 Comment

After a run on bringing in assistants from Boone, Eli Drinkwitz has gotten about the business of retention in Columbia.

In a press release, Missouri confirmed that Drinkwitz has decided to retain Brick Haley as part of his first coaching staff with the football program.  Haley wil continue on as the Tigers’ defensive line coach, and will carry the title of assistant head coach as well.

“In my short time of being around Brick I know him to be a man of high character who gets the most out of his players,” said Drinkwitz in a statement. “His wealth of knowledge with the defensive line is exactly what we’re looking for to motivate young men.”

Haley has spent the past three seasons with the Tigers.  Prior to that, he was the line coach at Texas (2015-16), LSU (2009-14) and Mississippi State (2004-06) at the collegiate level.

From 2007-08, Haley was the line coach for the NFL’s Chicago Bears.

“I’m grateful for the opportunity to continue at Mizzou and I’m excited to work with Coach Drink and his staff,” said Haley. “Our family loves Mizzou and being part of the Columbia community, so we’re thrilled to keep stakes in the ground here and I’m looking forward to getting to work on doing great things.”

Alex Hornibrook no longer with Florida State

Getty Images
2 Comments

It seems Alex Hornibrook‘s college career is complete.

Florida State interim head coach Odell Haggins said on Saturday that Hornibrook is no longer with the Seminoles as the club prepares for the Sun Bowl

He will join (former) teammate Cam Akers in that regard.

A graduate transfer from Wisconsin, Hornibrook appeared in five games this season. His peak as a Seminole came on Sept. 28, when he completed 29-of-40 passes for 316 yards with three touchdowns and no picks. For the year, Hornibrook hit 84-of-122 throws for 986 yards with seven scores versus two picks.

In three years at Wisconsin, Hornibrook threw for 5,438 yards and 47 touchdowns.

SMU WR Reggie Roberson, Jr., to return for senior season

Getty Images
1 Comment

SMU wide receiver Reggie Roberson, Jr., will return for his senior season in 2020, he announced earlier this week.

Roberson did so through a statement that at first read as if he would leave the Hilltop. “In the past couple of weeks, it has come to my attention that I am able to forgo my senior year and enter the NFL draft. I want to thank Coach Dykes for giving me the opportunity to come to SMU, and play the game I love in my hometown in front of my family and friends,” it began.

However, like a a classic Roberson open field move, he quickly changed directions and sprinted toward opportunity. “I have decided to come back and play my senior year at SMU. There is a lot of unfinished business that I left on the field that I need to take care of next season.”

A native of DeSoto, Texas, just south of Dallas, Roberson was one of SMU’s top players before he was lost to a foot injury in October. He caught 11 passes for 180 yards in the Ponies’ opening week win over Arkansas State and hauled in eight passes for 250 yards and three touchdowns in a 45-21 drubbing of Temple on Oct. 19.

For the year, Roberson caught 43 passes for 803 yards and six touchdowns over seven-plus games. Spread over a 13-game season, he was on pace to end the year in the neighborhood of 80 receptions for 1,500 yards and 11 touchdowns.

Roberson originally signed with West Virginia out of high school.

Zack Moss to play in Alamo Bowl

Getty Images
Leave a comment

It’s become A Thing ever since Christian McCaffrey bailed on Stanford for that Sun Bowl: Draft eligible players announcing whether or not their prep for the next level begins for or after their team’s upcoming bowl game.

For Utah running back Zack Moss, that will begin after the Alamo Bowl.

“I just wanted to play with my guys,” Moss told KSL Sports. “That was one of the reasons why I wanted to come back was to play with these guys and I definitely want to finish it off. I am healthy enough to play and that’s exactly what I want to do.

“I love this team, I love the program, coaching, fans and community, so why not give everyone one last game.”

Moss’s teammate Jaylon Johnson previously announced he will skip the game.

The senior will look to polish off a career in which he’s carried for 4,010 yards and 38 touchdowns.

No. 11 Utah will close the career of Moss and backfield mate Tyler Huntley opposite Texas on Dec. 31 (7:30 p.m., ESPN).