In a classic battle of Big Ten powers, Wisconsin’s defense won the first half. But Ohio State’s won the second half and it won overtime, helping the No. 2 Buckeyes erase a 10-point deficit to defeat No. 8 Wisconsin 30-23 in overtime.
It was not the best night for Ohio State’s offense, but the Buckeyes made the plays they needed to make when they needed to make them, including overcoming two penalties at the top of the first overtime to set J.T. Barrett up for a 7-yard touchdown strike to Noah Brown.
On the ensuing possession, Alex Hornibrook found Robert Wheelwright for a 21-yard connection to set the Badgers up for a first-and-goal at the Ohio State 4. They would move no further. Corey Clement was stuffed on first down, and Hornibook threw incomplete on second down. Clement again rushed for no gain on third down, and Hornibrook’s fourth down pass never actually left his hand. Seemingly the entire Ohio State front busted through the Wisconsin offensive line, causing a startled and backpedaling Hornibook to pump fake. He was engulfed before he could load another pass, and Ohio State had its 20th consecutive win inside an opponent’s stadium.
Wisconsin (4-2 and a hard-fought 1-2 in the Big Ten) controlled the pace and the mood throughout the first half, limiting the Buckeyes to just two field goals and taking a 16-6 lead to the break.
But the Badgers’ controlled attack worked against them in the third quarter, when a three-and-out and an interception allowed Ohio State consecutive scoring drives — neither of them covering 50 yards — to grab a 20-16 lead on an 8-yard Barrett run on 3rd-and-6 with 14:09 to play. Wisconsin immediately responded with a touchdown drive of its own, chewing up 81 yards and 6:15 of clock, to regain a 23-20 advantage midway through the frame.
Ohio State (6-0, 3-0 Big Ten) answered, largely on the back of a 43-yard pass to Dontre Wilson, to set Tyler Durbin up for a 31-yard field goal to tie the game with 3:57 remaining.
Barrett battled through drops, rough conditions and an active defense to complete 17-of-29 passes for 226 yards with a touchdown and an end zone interception while rushing 21 times for 92 yards and two more scores. Hornibrook hit 16 of his 28 throws for 214 yards with a touchdown and a pick, while Clement rushed 25 times for 164 yards.