A year after being upset by eventual national champion Ohio State in the College Football Playoff, Alabama dismantled Big Ten champion Michigan State in this year’s playoff en route to a national championship victory over Clemson. Alabama’s 38-0 blowout of Michigan State sent a rather loud message confirming Alabama was still a mighty force to reckon with. It also suggested Alabama had grown and improved from their initial playoff experience a year ago. There were some who felt Michigan State may have been deserving of a spot in the College Football Playoff based off overall body of work, but even some of those people would suggest the Spartans were not the best team in the Big Ten.
Despite losing at home to Michigan State late in the season, an argument could have been made Ohio State was the best team in the conference in 2015. The Buckeyes suffered a last-second loss in Columbus to Michigan State, opening the door for the Spartans to advance to the Big Ten Championship game, where it put together a masterful late touchdown drive to edge previously unbeaten Iowa in a defensive battle. Ohio State had to settle for knocking around rival Michigan in the first meeting between Urban Meyer and Jim Harbaugh. The Buckeyes went on to the Fiesta Bowl to face Notre Dame in the New Years Six line-up, but not without regrets for not defending its national title belt in the fatal four-way of the playoff. As Michigan State was blown away by Alabama, some Buckeyes could not help but think they would have had a better shot at giving Alabama a good fight once again.
“I think we would have definitely done a better job,” Ohio State defensive back Tyvis Powell said this week during Senior Bowl preparations in Mobile, Alabama (via Al.com). “I was shocked [Michigan State] didn’t score a point. It is what it is. It was very disappointing. But, Alabama, it was their year. I guess everybody has their year and it was their time to win.”
So what would have happened if the Buckeyes and Crimson Tide would have squared off one more time in this season’s playoff?
“I didn’t get to watch much film on them, but I know it would have been a hell of a game,” Ohio State tight end Nick Vannett said. “(Alabama) might have done a little better this year than they were last year. And I think the way we played in the last couple of games, we could have played against any team in the country. I know it would have been another war like it was the year before. So it would have been interesting to see.”
It sure would have been interesting to see. Maybe next year?