Why isn’t every coach on a coach of the year award watch list?

4 Comments

In the latest piece of evidence that confirms we do in fact have a watch list for everything and anything, the Bobby Dodd Coach of the Year Foundation released a watch list of college football coaches for their 2015 award. Among the 25 coaches  deemed worthy of such a preseason honor are past winners Paul Johnson, Gary Patterson, Nick Saban, Bill Snyder, Bob Stoops and Dabo Swinney. Three-time national championship coach Urban Meyer is also on the list. So are the other two coaches from last season’s College Football Playoff, Jimbo Fisher and Mark Helfrich.

My question is simple. If we have watch lists naming almost every center on one award watch list, shouldn’t every coach of an FBS program be listed on a watch list for a coach of the year award? While it is nice to get an idea of some of the top position players in college football with the help of some watch lists for various awards, coaches should be evaluated on a different scale. We know who the top coaches at the top programs are, watch list or no watch list. Having a preseason watch list for this award defeats the purpose of the award’s ultimate goal.

Everybody has their opinions on what should make a coach of the year. Is it assembling and coaching the best team possible during the course of a season? If so, then these would appear to be worthy names to consider, as are the rest of the names on the watch list. Or is the intent of a coach of the year award more to honor a coach who defied expectations or battled through the most adversity to lead his team to victories few saw coming? If so, then there is no possible way to predict which coach will be worthy of mentioning in the conversation when the season is nearing an end.

Of course, watch lists are all about preseason publicity. You may have spent a summer day thinking about which player might win the Heisman Trophy in December. Have you ever gone through a summer and given one thought to who might win the Bobby Dodd Coach of the Year Award? No? Well, now you might, thanks to the release of this watch list that has absolutely no business seeing the light of day (and the media types that fall for the stunt to let you know about it; guilty as charged).

2015 Bobby Dodd Coach of the Year Award Watch List

Art Briles, Baylor
Mark Dantonio, Michigan State
Jimbo Fisher, Florida State
Hugh Freeze, Ole Miss
Bryan Harsin, Boise State
Mark Helfrich, Oregon
Paul Johnson, Georgia Tech
Brian Kelly, Notre Dame
Gus Malzahn, Auburn
Urban Meyer, Ohio State
Jim Mora, UCLA
Dan Mullen, Mississippi State
Gary Patterson, TCU
Gary Pinkel, Missouri
Mark Richt, Georgia
Rich Rodriguez, Arizona
Nick Saban, Alabama
Bill Snyder, Kansas State
Steve Spurrier, South Carolina
Bob Stoops, Oklahoma
Kevin Sumlin, Texas A&M
Dabo Swinney, Clemson
Kyle Whittingham, Utah

FAU TE John Raine awarded another year of eligibility

Getty Images
Leave a comment

We overlooked this one earlier in the week, but it’s a rather sizable piece of official news for Lane Kiffin‘s Florida Atlantic football program.

By way of the Palm Beach Post Tuesday, it has been confirmed that John Raine was recently awarded a fifth season of eligibility.  The ruling will allow the senior tight end to play for the Owls in 2020.

A broken ankle cost Raine all but four games of his true freshman season in 2016, paving the way for the NCAA to rule in his favor on his appeal for another year of eligibility.

“I’m super excited about it,” Raine told the Post about the NCAA’s approval of a medical hardship waiver. “I love being here; I love playing football.”

With two regular-season games plus a bowl remaining, Rainer has already set career-highs in receptions (26), receiving yards (426) and receiving touchdowns (five).  The touchdowns are tops on the Owls.

This weekend, a Notre Dame home game won’t be sold out for first time since 1973

Getty Images
3 Comments

All good things, streaks in this particular case, must come to an end.

Saturday afternoon in South Bend, Notre Dame will play host to Navy in the 93rd renewal of their football rivalry.  And, according to the South Bend Tribune, the game won’t be played in front of a sellout crowd at Notre Dame Stadium (capacity: 77,622), which is actually a startling development.

This weekend, you see, will mark the first time since Thanksgiving Day 1973 (vs. Air Force) that the Fighting Irish haven’t sold out a home football game, snapping a streak of 273 straight sellouts.  Ahead of that streak being snapped, the Irish’s athletic director for the past dozen years, Jack Swarbrick, attempted to downplay the development.

From the Tribune:

It was never sort of important to me to keep it alive, but I understand why other people thought so. It’s a point of distinction to a lot of people and our fans.

“For me it’s always been: What’s the stadium environment like? Are we creating a great environment for our team and for our student-athletes? That you can say it’s also sold out is sort of a byproduct of that.

“But if my choice is (77,622) people in an environment that’s not really good versus 75,000 in a raucous environment, I’ll take the latter every time.

Notre Dame’s 237-game streak had been the second-longest active streak in college football behind Nebraska’s 373, which will move to 374 when Big Red hosts Wisconsin this weekend. The last time the Cornhuskers failed to sellout Memorial Stadium was during the 1962 season.

Four finalists named for 2019 Paul Hornung Award

Getty Images
1 Comment

The field for the award that fetes the nation’s most versatile college football player has been whittled down significantly.

Earlier Thursday, the Louisville Sports Commission announced the four finalists for the 2019 Paul Hornung Award that have been chosen by the 17-member selection committee.  And (surprise!), all four of the finalists come from Power Five conferences: Lynn Bowden Jr. (Kentucky), Clyde Edwards-Helaire (LSU), Joe Reed (Virginia) and Wan’Dale Robinson (Nebraska).

All four of the finalists come from the offensive side of the ball and have spent time as return specialists as well.  Because of injuries at the position, Bowden, listed as a wide receiver to start the season, has started the last three games at quarterback for UK, with the Wildcats going 2-1 in that span.

Reed is primarily a wide receiver and Edwards-Helaire a running back, while Robinson has split his time between both positions.

The 2018 winner of the Hornung Award was Purdue’s Rondale Moore, who likely would’ve been given serious finalist consideration again this year if not for his season essentially being derailed by a lingering hamstring injury.

For all of the statistical particulars for each candidate, click HERE the award’s press release:

 

Texas’ Jalen Green apologizes for vicious hit that angered K-State

Getty Images
2 Comments

It appears Kansas State will have to settle for a mea culpa.

In the second half of last Saturday’s game, Texas cornerback Jalen Green (pictured) leveled K-State wide receiver Wykeen Gill (not pictured) on a play away from the ball and was ejected from the contest after (eventually) being flagged for targeting.  The play will cost Green the first half of UT’s game this Saturday against Iowa State per NCAA targeting rules, but will likely cost Gill at least one full game as he will be sidelined for the Week 12 matchup with West Virginia as the receiver is currently in concussion protocol.

That disparity didn’t sit well with K-State’s head coach.

“It’s unfortunate because it was away from the play, didn’t have anything to do with the play, and Wykeen is probably going to miss a game,” Chris Klieman stated at his weekly press conference Tuesday. “When you have a hit like that and somebody only misses a half, I don’t think that’s very fair.”

Wednesday afternoon, Green issued an apology in which he stated, in part, that he “realize[s] how it may have looked” but “I do want everyone to know I was not trying to take a cheap shot.”

As for “not trying to take a cheap shot,” you be the judge.